Episiotomy… Help or hinderance?
Monday, April 30th, 2007An episiotomy is a surgical incision in the perineum (the area of the skin between the vagina and the anus). It is one of the most common surgical procedures in childbirth and is quite surprising considering that in most cases, they are unnecessary and can do more harm than good. Episiotomies DO have their place in birth, but only as needed and not routinely.
Episiotomies and tears are measured in degrees. The most common episiotomy is a 2nd degree, midway between the vagina and anus), and the least common and biggest being a 4th degree tear that extends through the rectum (ouch!). There are also different types of episiotomies - the midline is the most common (extends directly towards the anus) and the mediolaterial which is a diagonal cut toward either side of the anus.
Why an episiotomy?
These incisions are cut to enlarge the opening as the baby comes out to deliver a baby quickly or to try and prevent a woman from tearing naturally. Most commonly claimed ”benefits” are: speedy delivery (in the case where birth is immenent, but the baby must be born quickly due to distress or other complications), it prevents tearing, protects against incontenence, heals easier than tears, and protects against pelvic floor relaxation. Many women are cut because doctors claim the skin is too tight to stretch over the baby’s head and as a result, tearing is going to happen unless she is cut. Or the baby “needs” to be delivered quickly because birth is taking too long (when there are no complications or fetal distress - we must remember birth is not a timed event). In many cases, episiotomies are simply routine procedures that our insurance pays for (or that we pay for out of our own pockets).
Surprisingly, many of the above cited benefits have never been proven true by medical research and many of them are actually false.
Did you know that in study after study, one of the most common risk factors for 3rd and 4th degree tears is an episiotomy, the very procedure used to protect women from large tears!
Our skin becomes more prone to tear when it has already been cut. So, if you have an episiotomy, your skin will be more likely to rip deeper as it is stretched from the baby’s head crowning. If women were able to birth their babies nice and slow, in positions that would allow better fetal position and delivery, with perineal support, the chance of tearing reduces dramatically. If a tear does occur, in most instances it will be small unless your birth involves forced pushing, instrumental delivery (in which case an episiotomy will be cut), poor positioning and rough handling.
Episiotomies are not without their risks. The most common risks and side effects reported include infection, increased pain, increase in 3rd and 4th degree vaginal lacerations (an extention from the episiotomy), longer healing times and increase discomfort when intercourse is resumed.
That being said, episiotomies do have their place. For delivery where instruments are required (forceps, vaccum), an enlarged opening will be required. In many cases if a quick birth is needed to deliver a baby, getting into a squat can enlarge your pelvic opening to allow that baby more space to flex/extend/rotate his way out of your body. But if assistance is required, an episiotomy has it’s place to enlarge the opening and allow what needs to be done to be done.
Your position during birth can have a lot to do with tearing… If your doctor suggests a cut, you might suggest changing position if you are able to, or perineal support to see if that helps things at all. I know with my daughter, I birthed her in the classical “on your back” position and I did tear slightly delivering my 6 lb. baby. Then delivering my son at home on hands and knees, my 7lb 5 oz baby was born without so much as a skidmark! This is very common.
Prenatally, you can do the following to help prevent tearing in the first place: eat a healthy diet (healthy skin stretches more easily), kegals (exercises for the pelvic floor), prenatal perineal massage, slowed second stage (careful pushing), warm compresses, perineal massage and support during delivery. Reducing the chance of tearing will reduce the possibility that your doctor will suggest an episiotomy to prevent tearing ![]()