Sep 23 2007
Build the Nuke Plant, DTE
I find it fascinating to watch what is going on right now in our area.
In Lansing, we have legislators locking themselves into legislative chambers, attempting to make backroom deals to save the state.
In Detroit, we have UAW leaders and auto plant CEO’s hammering away, far from the light of day, at a landmark contract deal.
And in Monroe, we have power plant executives deciding the future of our lakefront and energy supply.
Each one of these backroom moves has the chance to revolutionize thousands of lives.
On the power plant front, Consumer’s Energy decided to build a coal power plant near Saginaw Bay rather than in Erie Township.
I don’t see this as necessarily a bad thing. I hope that the future of the Erie Township shoreline and Luna Pier is one of housing, parks, trails and marinas rather than coal power production. The current plant will likely run for several more decades. But I think that the area is more valuable for its recreational, residential and natural aspects.
The Consumer’s Energy decision, however, makes it even more important now that DTE move forward with its plans to construct a new nuclear plant at the site of Fermi II. The decision, apparently, will come in the next 12 to 18 months.
We simply can’t let the power industry leave Monroe over the long term. It insulates Monroe from some of the vagaries of the auto industry and provides jobs and tax base for most everything that goes on in the county.
And the nuclear option will help Monroe to avoid any future moves against the terrible impacts of coal power generation. We need only look to New York State and Elliot Spitzer’s attempts to force businesses to declare the environmental liability of carbon production on corporate balance sheets. Closer to home, we can see the cleaner and shorter third tower at the Monroe DTE facility. They didn’t build that tower out of the goodness of their hearts. I think that DTE can see the handwriting on the wall. Cleaner is better. The alternative is that we might one day find ourselves in the same position as the southern tobacco farmers - tied to an industry hammered by impossible liability.
Nuclear power is certainly not “green” in the traditional sense of the word. But it does avoid the thousands of annual deaths that result from coal energy production. And I think that we’ve seen with Fermi that a plant can be safe if properly run.
I would hope that DTE would also implement other green power initiatives at the Fermi site. How about an offshore field of wind turbines near the plant? Or how about a new design that doesn’t dominate the sightlines like the current cooling towers do?
The future will not be perfect. But I think that another nuke plant will help Monroe to stay in the power game long term. And I think that it would help us to have a cleaner local environment as well.
