Trolling reels are much the same as the casting reels with some differences. As far as companies go, the reccomendations are the same three; Daiwa, Ambassadeur or Shimano. The reasons why, and their applications set them apart. There is one kicker brand at the end.
Why a Daiwa, simply because of their track record and the performance of their linecounter reels. Folks are begining to realize it is just as important to know the amount of line you have it out, as it is in walleye fishing. If you want to consistently put the baits back where they have been getting hits the reel can do it. The drag is the key here, if the reel can handle a 300′ run by a 20 to 30 lb salmon, it will serve you well for muskie fishing. The reel you want for muskie would be the SG 47 LCA, and for pike the SG 27 LCA will get the job done.
The Ambassadeur line up has a uniquely built reel. The C3 7000 is a lot like a Ford, they are BUILT TOUGH. Hopefully there isn’t a copyright infringement in me saying that! The reel is solid, and when you see it you can quickly understand why. Metal, metal and more metal. Although not a linecounter, the reel will suit you well for regular trolling, but really shines when using ball weights off the side or behind the boat. Very similiar to using downriggers, and somewhat related to fishing with bottom bouncers, the heavy weights can quickly get the baits down to the strike area.
Shimano has a graphite bodied reel, the TR 200, which can do what the 7000 can, but at a cheaper price. You should be able to find these reels for under $70 any place. They used to be only $60. A good reel, just not built like the big C3. They also have a linecounter available that has been gaining in popularity, the Tekota series. A well built, but spendy reel, the 500 LC is the choice for the dedicated pike guys, while the 600 LC would be your muskie reel. Both of these reels are their linecounter models, but they are also available without that feature.
Finally the kicker, Penn has long been known for building some of the best saltwater reels on the market. If the drags can hold up for deep sea fishing, they will hold up extremely well for muskie fishing. The GTi 310 and 320 are your pike choices, while the 320 and the GTi 330 are your muskie choices. Its all about the drag and pure cranking power when you use these reels.
