
Is this the reason your not seeing many deer this year? At least one group of hunters has their own idea about the declining Michigan deer population.
Just this evening I talked to my brother-in-law Pat Boylan who recently returned from deer hunting around Wellston Michigan. He stayed with his buddy Jim Chapman and five other hunters in camp. Jim knows the area well and most years he has no trouble filling out two of his deer tags.
Those seven guys hunted several days of bow season plus 4-5 days of gun season and came home empty handed. Jim cannot recall that ever happening in the 20 some years he’s been hunting the area. The talk around their camp was centered on “What the heck has happened to the deer herd?” Pat hunted the Udall Hills area, and he reported finding several deer skeletons on his travels. There are many coyote in the area, as the guys saw and heard them on numerous occasions. Could these little wolves be the culprits? The consensus was a resounding “NO.” Sure coyotes are taking some deer down, but to the degree that changes a hunting “hot-spot” into a “dead” zone, no way.
Here’s what the guys came up with, and agree with them or not, It’s what they believe. There has been a total baiting ban for two seasons now, and according to Jim, and his hunting buddies, they noticed a decline in deer numbers during the late December deer season. The seven hunters covered alot of ground, and to a man were sorely disappointed by the number of deer spotted.
Wellston is in one of Michigan’s snow belt areas, and gets tons of the white stuff every year. The theory is that baiting has helped keep the deer healthy enough to make it through this areas brutal winters. Most guys purchase several hundred pounds of bait corn, carrots, sugar beats, and apples. The various bait piles, spread out over most of the deers range, allows the does, fawns, and bucks to fatten up for whats ahead. It benefits the deer, and on occasion puts some venison in the freezer. The guys agree that without this extra boast in the deers food supply, deer numbers are going to plummet. This is not an agricultural area where the deer can visit a corn or soy-bean field all winter.
They can’t understand how one lone deer, being raised in a fenced in area, could cause a statewide ban on baiting! The question was asked about the effects on the overall deer herd due to this one private deer enclosure having a case of CWD? As it stands now, the hunters figure tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of deer died off over the last two years due to the baiting ban.
Who benefits from this scenario they ask? Why it couldn’t be the insurance companies could it? Pat said he’d eat his muzzle-loader if the car/deer crashes had not gone down over this two year period. The guys in this little hunting camp firmly believe someone in the “upper echelons” of government are in “bed” with the insurance companies. Interesting theory, and not all that crazy considering all the “sweetheart deals” that go on behind closed doors.
A secondary effect of the baiting ban is how it has brutalized the Mom and Pop stores bottom line. Many of these little places of business depended on the extra income (from bait sales) to get them through the slow winter months. Just like the deer many of them are now gone also. Economically the little peons in Michigan took a huge hit, but I bet the Insurance Industries bottom line more than offsets what the small business owners lost. But that’s just a bunch of deer camp talk, by a few of the guys that pay the salaries of our duly elected officials. I’m thinking those seven guys got a better idea whats going on in the woods than some “desk jockey” making life changing decisions for the rest of us. What do you think?
Mike