$300 Million Requested For More Federal e-Spies
Friday, February 29th, 2008The Bush Administration is seeking a new tool for spying on Americans and foreigners. The system, referred to as Einstein, would monitor anyone who visits a .gov website. The Department of Homeland Security has described it as “an automated process for collecting, correlating, analyzing, and sharing computer security information across the federal civilian government.”
The program is already active in 15 federal agencies and DHS Secretary, Michael Chertoff, has requested nearly $300 million for expand it to include all agencies.
“Whenever a system monitors users’ communications, privacy concerns naturally arise, said James Lewis, who runs the technology policy wing of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, a Washington think tank, and is working with members of Congress to devise cybersecurity policy recommendations for the next president. In this case, however, he said he didn’t see any reason to be alarmed about Einstein quite yet.
“For Einstein to really affect privacy, you’d need to monitor and collect the communications, store them, and analyze them (e.g. have somebody actually read the content),” he said in an e-mail interview after Thursday’s hearing. “I’m told that DHS won’t store Einstein data and won’t be analyzing it, which greatly reduces any risk to privacy.”
Apparently his definition of analyzing is completely different from that of the DHS which had this to say:
“Homeland Security says the setup has helped reduce the time it takes for agencies to share such data from four to five days to four to five hours. The next step is to hire more analysts and enable the analysis to occur in real time, DHS says.”
So either James isn’t being completely honest or the DHS misspoke and wants $300 million to pretend like it’s doing something to benefit our security — not an entirely unbelievable scenario.