When debating the legitimacy of taxation, I’m often confronted with the claim that we are obligated to pay taxes because we benefit from government services, whether or not we consent to paying them. If this is generally accepted logic, then I’m going to start clearing people’s driveways after it snows — without first getting their permission — and demand compensation at a rate of $50/hour. They should comply, and appreciate what I’ve done for them. After all, they’ll probably need to use their driveways; and if so, they’ll undoubtedly benefit from my hard work.